Jump to content
  • Welcome to SEFP!

    Welcome!

    Welcome to our community forums, full of great discussions about Structural Engineering. Please register to become a part of our thriving group or login if you are already registered.

Bhagirath Joshi

Help required for analysis in etabs

Recommended Posts

Hello everyone,

I wanted a help regarding the problem I've been facing during building analysis using etabs. The analysis displays the minimum steel for every column, what might have been the error or problem?

Also ,is providing diaphragm for area components and meshing them necessary during analysis of building in etabs?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
33 minutes ago, Bhagirath Joshi said:

The analysis displays the minimum steel for every column, what might have been the error or problem?

There may be several reasons for this. For example,

- provided columns are of a larger size, or

- there are a number of shear walls, or

- you might have erroneously assigned support property to the column joints at all storey levels, instead of those at base level, etc.

You should recheck your model carefully to determine, what might be the real reason for the results obtained.

45 minutes ago, Bhagirath Joshi said:

Also ,is providing diaphragm for area components and meshing them necessary during analysis of building in etabs?

Assigning of diaphram is necessary for proper accounting of stiffness of the structure, to resist lateral  forces (earthquake etc).

Meshing is essential for the transfer of slab load to the edge beams more uniformly.

HTH

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You haven't provided any details regarding your structure, e.g., geometry, spans, no. of stories, building usage, seismic zone, etabs version being used, etc. etc. As such, it is difficult to give more suggestions.

If you could attach your model file here, people here might help you in a better way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dear Uzair, I'm also facing the same problem.my building is in zone 2A,soil sd,all spans are less than 25ft,slab thickness 6",size of columns and beams are 12"x30" and 9"x18" respectively. Seismic load cases are 4. End result is all columns are having steel 1%.is it ok to have same %age in all columns? Or something is definitely wrong?

Secondly building shape is pretty regular and no of stories are eight.rigid diaphragm assigned.etabs version 9.7.5. but i just remember i erroneously defined 25% live load in mass source command as the building is for purely residential purpose as against Warehouse or a garrage where we define 25% of L.L.?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dear Abid 

please share your model and architectural plans, so that somebody could review it. one major reason is of assigning supports at all levels and second is oversize members(columns,beams) as uzair sab mentioned above, 3rd is shorter spans and equal loads going to columns.

regards

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dear waqar I'm uploading architecture and edb file of the model.i have separated the building by providing expansion joint.the file in etabs model is one portion of the building, I'm working on it.secondly if we dont want to provide expansion joint thn wat to do? coz when i model the entire building then lots of errors are coming so i separated the building now there aren't any errors.all suggestions will be highly appreciated.thnx n regards

STATIC MODEL.EDB

STATIC MODEL.$ET

AMMALGAMATION PLAN-Model.pdf

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 1/21/2017 at 2:18 PM, Abid Qasmi said:

Dear waqar I'm uploading architecture and edb file of the model.i have separated the building by providing expansion joint.the file in etabs model is one portion of the building, I'm working on it.secondly if we dont want to provide expansion joint thn wat to do? coz when i model the entire building then lots of errors are coming so i separated the building now there aren't any errors.all suggestions will be highly appreciated.thnx n regards

STATIC MODEL.EDB

STATIC MODEL.$ET

AMMALGAMATION PLAN-Model.pdf

Dear all,i found out the reason why column reinforcement was 1℅ in all columns and it was that i had erroneously assigned oversized column dimensions in some columns. But my second querry yet remains unanswered that is whether the building be modelled as a whole or separated into two portions in order to avoid errors.thnx n regards

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Our picks

    • AOA 

      i am facing problems in shear wall design .what are the pier and spandral ?what will be the difference when we assign pier or spandral? without assigning these the shear wall design is incomplete .

      i am taking about etabsv16

      someone have document about shear wall design plz provide it 

      thank you

       
      • 9 replies
    • Salam Members,

      Congratulations to Engineers, PEC has become full signatory of Washington Accord, what are the benefits to Pakistani engineers for this agreement. 

       

      Regards   

       

       
      • 3 replies
    • Please clarify the following confusions one by one:-

       

      1. If we run P-delta analysis in ETABS, then should we ignore stiffness property modifiers for beams and columns? I have heard that if we perform P-delta analysis and apply stiffness modifiers at the same time then the moment magnification process is doubled...?

       

      2. ETABS considers selenderness of a column by applying moment magnification factors. If we run P-delta analysis also, does it mean that the selenderness of column is being over-estimated? I mean once the moments are magnified in P-delta analysis process and again through moment magnification process?

       

      Please help me understand the software myth and clarify above confusions.
      • 1 reply
    • Assalam o alaikum.
      According to ACI 12.5.2,
      development length for fc' = 3000, fy=60000, for normal weight concrete and epoxy less reinforcement, The required development length comes out to be
      for #3 = 8.2 inch
      for #4 = 10.95 inch
      for #6 = 16.42 inch
      for #8 = 21.9 inch
       
      And if in my case, ACI 12.5.3 is not fulfilled, it means now i have to provide ldh as mentioned above. ldh is STRAIGHT EMBEDMENT LENGTH + RADIUS OF BEND + ONE BAR DIAMETER as shown in figure attached. Now my question is, if in my case, main reinforcement of beam is of #6 and #4, minimum column size required will be 18 inch and 12 inch respectively. Lets say by any means, i can not select #4, #3 bars and size of column where bars are to be terminated is 12 inch, how to fullfil this development length???
      • 11 replies
    • Dear all,

      I am trying to design shearwalls through ETABS with temperature load applied over shell. At various location, spandral section fails in Shear due to temperature and piers (sometime in shear, mostly in flexure).  (See Attached Image)

      Certainly all the problem in Shearwalls are due to temperature. I don't want to increase cross section of spandral or pier at some location just due to temperature load case as it will appears non-uniform with rest of the wall. 

      I have seen stiffness modifier affect distribution of forces and also rigid/semi rigid daiphragm assumption. 

       

      Can anybody guide how to properly design the shear wall with temperature load applied in ETABS or share any similar experience. Thanks in Advance.    
      • 15 replies
    • ENGINEERS;
      I WILL LOOSE MY BRAIN FROM ETABS. 
      I DECIDED TO MAKE MANUAL MESHING FROM AREA ELEMENTS BESIDE EACH OTHER AND EVERY HING WAS FINE .
      BUT AFTER DEVISION SAY 7*7 ELEMNTS FOR EVERY BIG ELEMENT AND MAKING ETABS CHECH..................THEN 500 ERROR MESSAGE THAT ALL ELEMNTS ARE CLOSE TO EACH OTHER.  WHAT ARE GOING...... SOMEONE TELL ME PLEASE...... I WILL LOST MY WORK
      • 6 replies
    • Assalam o alaikum.
      I have just designed a frame structure with SMRF. The out put of shear seams weird to me. Column reports design shear Av/s as 0.045. (Images are attached). but when i right click the member, it must show me the most critical case HIGHLIGHTED AUTOMATICALLY. But it highlights load combo 38 (auto-generated combos have been used) which reports Av/s as 0.038. And 0.045 value is at combo 32. Is their any logic behind it?? More over how to interpret this Av/s?? means 0.045 in kip-in units means what? How can i convert this into spacing?? 
      • 9 replies
    • Hello everyone, I hope all of you will be fine. In etabs when we apply Response Spectrum loading on a multistoried building with 2 basement floors. At what floor level this loading will be applied as in equivalent static seismic analysis, we can apply EQX & EQY on any floor we like as this option is available in etabs but the problem is with response spectrum and time history analysis. please if someone knows and have the experince, share it i shall be very thankful.  
      • 5 replies
    • Salaikom dear professionals,
      First of all I would like to express my sincere thanks to the initiators of this forum for establishing such an exceptional atmosphere for knowledge/experience sharing, I it is really useful, In fact since I have found the forum I am mostly online and busy reading the posts. I would also like to thank the members for their professional comments and advice.
      As my first post in this forum I would like to ask the following queries:
      1-After running the analysis and design when I check the DESIGN DATA through Display >> Show Tables >> DESIGN DATA >> Concrete Frame Output, there is no specific message in Column Summary Data and Beam Summary Data, but in Joint summary data it is showing that “Joint B/C check not done”. Does anyone has any idea? I am sharing the ETABS model for your information and easy reference.
      ETABS MODEL.zip
      2- ETABS provides greater area of steel in the upper column than the column at BASE, perhaps due to higher moment. Could someone explain why this is so? In practice should we maintain maximum steel in both stories? Or we shall follow what the software suggests?
      3- Beside considering the minimum thickness required for deflection control of Beam as per Table 9.a Chapter 9 ACI-318 , using concrete crack behavior in ETABS and checking story drift, Do we have to check the deflection of beams for the serviceability propose elsewhere in ETBAS? If yes, Could anyone explain it?
      Regards, and look forward to any explanation
      • 13 replies
    • Posting this thread to break the ice. Modelling domes is very easy in Etabs/SAP. All you need to do is to draw the curvature of the dome in elevation by a series of straight lines, but draw only the one half. Then using the apex at centre point, radially extrude the line say 24 times at 15 degree intervals (or 48 times at 7.5 deg intervals. This feature is under Edit> Extrude Lines to areas. You can further use this geometry for Finite Element Analaysis.
      • 22 replies
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Recent Discussions

  • Latest Forum and Club Posts

    • According to ACI Concrete Terminology 2013,  a "beam" is defined as " a structural member subjected primarily to flexure but may also be subjected to axial load." Whereas, a "column" is a "member with a ratio of height-to-least-lateral-dimension exceeding 3 used primarily to support axial compressive load." Design of a structural member (as a beam or column) in ACI 318 code is based on above-mentioned definitions. Regards.
    • Hello everyone, what clause of the code specify that a given member shall be designed as a beam or as a column?
    • hi every body i ask if one here know about Coefficient of  thermal expansion homogeneity of reinforced concrete with steel bars vs. reinforced concrete with glass fiber reinforced plastic GFRP.
    • Dear Shafqat, AA. Field work of a civil engineer generally consists of following activities: a. Surveying / levelling of the project area b. Supervision of construction work for buildings, roads, culverts, bridges etc., in accordance with detailed working drawings, applicable material specifications and quality standards. c. Preparation of material estimates, by calculating quantities of different items of work (e.g., excavation, concrete, brickwork, plaster, reinforcing steel etc-in case of buildings, and subbase, base, wearing course etc, in case of roadwork) included in working drawings of the project. 2. To perform all these tasks in better & efficient way, you will need to review your class notes & text books of relevant subjects (Surveying, Civil Engineering Practice, Estimating & Costing, Highways & Roads, Engineering Materials) taught during your civil engineering studies, in order to understand theoretical & practical aspects of these subjects. 3. As regards, which subject you should review first, would depend upon the work you are asked /assigned to do by your senior engineer. As a Trainee Engineer, you will certainly be attached with a senior engineer, who will assign you different engineering tasks & check your work. You may & must obtain his advice in all the work matters, where you are in doubt, or unclear about how to perform a given task. 4. In case you have futher querries, please do ask, by narrating your problem in detail. I will be happy to help you, as far as I can. By the way, what kind of civil works are carried out by your company mostly? Building work, roadwork or both? Regards.
    • Dear Shafqat Hussain Welcome to the forum. Check what you require at the job and discuss with your seniors, ask them for help if you do not understand something. At first job mostly you don not know exactly what to do but the main engineering profession skill is lifelong learning which comes forward and you learn new things. Contact some senior surveyor for the level and theodolite guidance.   Regards
    • , i just graduated as bachelor   in civil engineering i got the job in chinese company due to my chinese language skill but i don"t know knowledge about civil engineering so i need some information to continue this job because i can speak chinese and don't know about my major , my duty is as trainee engineer mean and i want  to get more  knowledge about level ,instrument measure  and theodolite    it will really great help that what kind of knowledge i should learn mean while  i will be waiting for reply 
    • Following are a few disadvantages of using higher strength rebars with a lower strength concrete: 1. Larger tension (as well as compression) development & lap-splice lengths will be required. 2. Overall load carrying capacity of a compression member will be lesser, compared with when higher strength concrete is used. 3. Maximum amount of steel reinforcement, that can be used in a flexural member, will also be lesser, thereby reducing its overall load carrying capacity. 4. Member size & self-weight will be somewhat larger, when steel yield strength is more than 60,000 psi. Regards.    
    • What kind of Problem may arise if High Strength Rebar is used with Low Strength Concrete. Say 3000 psi concrete with 72.5 grade rebar?
    • I agree with waqar. IMO, childern must be motivated towards & provided opportunities to play different health improving outdoor games (football, cricket, badminton, etc) , instead of watching TV or playing games on computer. My chidren are school going, and whenever they have done their homework, and it is pleasant outside (especially after Asr prayer), I send them out in a nearby park area. There they can play football or cricket, and can do exercise as well. On weekends, during vacations and on other days when they are unable to go outside, they generally watch tv for 1-2 hours.
    • Greetings All,   Technopole industries is a UAE based pole manufacturing factory which is currently in a requirement for a hard working, let me repeat that again an extremely hard working structural engineering to be part of our team. The Factory manufactures Steel poles & Mast more information can be found on Technopole Industries website. interested candidates can inbox me or drop their CV at fawad@technopoleindustries.com. Best Of Luck Guys
×

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Guidelines.