Jump to content
  • Welcome to SEFP!

    Welcome!

    Welcome to our community forums, full of great discussions about Structural Engineering. Please register to become a part of our thriving group or login if you are already registered.

Waqas Haider

ETABS beam design formulas from verification manual

Recommended Posts

Assalam o alaikum,

I was reading ETABS concrete frame design manual ACI 318-08. In beam design section, it gives two formulae which I am unable to find in books. One formula for stress block depth and one formula for negative steel calculation. I have highlighted the formulae in below images. The manual design using these formulae and conventional formulae gives the same result. But kindly guide me from where I can get derivation of these formulae or theory behind this.  

Beam image 1.png

beam image 2.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Waqas, just reverse calculate;

In books you will find for singly reinforced;

a = Asfy/0.85f'cb

and Phi Mn = 0.9Asfy(d-a/2)

re-arrange, and you will find your answer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Our picks

    • AOA 

      i am facing problems in shear wall design .what are the pier and spandral ?what will be the difference when we assign pier or spandral? without assigning these the shear wall design is incomplete .

      i am taking about etabsv16

      someone have document about shear wall design plz provide it 

      thank you

       
      • 9 replies
    • Salam Members,

      Congratulations to Engineers, PEC has become full signatory of Washington Accord, what are the benefits to Pakistani engineers for this agreement. 

       

      Regards   

       

       
      • 3 replies
    • Please clarify the following confusions one by one:-

       

      1. If we run P-delta analysis in ETABS, then should we ignore stiffness property modifiers for beams and columns? I have heard that if we perform P-delta analysis and apply stiffness modifiers at the same time then the moment magnification process is doubled...?

       

      2. ETABS considers selenderness of a column by applying moment magnification factors. If we run P-delta analysis also, does it mean that the selenderness of column is being over-estimated? I mean once the moments are magnified in P-delta analysis process and again through moment magnification process?

       

      Please help me understand the software myth and clarify above confusions.
      • 1 reply
    • Assalam o alaikum.
      According to ACI 12.5.2,
      development length for fc' = 3000, fy=60000, for normal weight concrete and epoxy less reinforcement, The required development length comes out to be
      for #3 = 8.2 inch
      for #4 = 10.95 inch
      for #6 = 16.42 inch
      for #8 = 21.9 inch
       
      And if in my case, ACI 12.5.3 is not fulfilled, it means now i have to provide ldh as mentioned above. ldh is STRAIGHT EMBEDMENT LENGTH + RADIUS OF BEND + ONE BAR DIAMETER as shown in figure attached. Now my question is, if in my case, main reinforcement of beam is of #6 and #4, minimum column size required will be 18 inch and 12 inch respectively. Lets say by any means, i can not select #4, #3 bars and size of column where bars are to be terminated is 12 inch, how to fullfil this development length???
      • 11 replies
    • Dear all,

      I am trying to design shearwalls through ETABS with temperature load applied over shell. At various location, spandral section fails in Shear due to temperature and piers (sometime in shear, mostly in flexure).  (See Attached Image)

      Certainly all the problem in Shearwalls are due to temperature. I don't want to increase cross section of spandral or pier at some location just due to temperature load case as it will appears non-uniform with rest of the wall. 

      I have seen stiffness modifier affect distribution of forces and also rigid/semi rigid daiphragm assumption. 

       

      Can anybody guide how to properly design the shear wall with temperature load applied in ETABS or share any similar experience. Thanks in Advance.    
      • 15 replies
    • ENGINEERS;
      I WILL LOOSE MY BRAIN FROM ETABS. 
      I DECIDED TO MAKE MANUAL MESHING FROM AREA ELEMENTS BESIDE EACH OTHER AND EVERY HING WAS FINE .
      BUT AFTER DEVISION SAY 7*7 ELEMNTS FOR EVERY BIG ELEMENT AND MAKING ETABS CHECH..................THEN 500 ERROR MESSAGE THAT ALL ELEMNTS ARE CLOSE TO EACH OTHER.  WHAT ARE GOING...... SOMEONE TELL ME PLEASE...... I WILL LOST MY WORK
      • 6 replies
    • Assalam o alaikum.
      I have just designed a frame structure with SMRF. The out put of shear seams weird to me. Column reports design shear Av/s as 0.045. (Images are attached). but when i right click the member, it must show me the most critical case HIGHLIGHTED AUTOMATICALLY. But it highlights load combo 38 (auto-generated combos have been used) which reports Av/s as 0.038. And 0.045 value is at combo 32. Is their any logic behind it?? More over how to interpret this Av/s?? means 0.045 in kip-in units means what? How can i convert this into spacing?? 
      • 9 replies
    • Hello everyone, I hope all of you will be fine. In etabs when we apply Response Spectrum loading on a multistoried building with 2 basement floors. At what floor level this loading will be applied as in equivalent static seismic analysis, we can apply EQX & EQY on any floor we like as this option is available in etabs but the problem is with response spectrum and time history analysis. please if someone knows and have the experince, share it i shall be very thankful.  
      • 5 replies
    • Salaikom dear professionals,
      First of all I would like to express my sincere thanks to the initiators of this forum for establishing such an exceptional atmosphere for knowledge/experience sharing, I it is really useful, In fact since I have found the forum I am mostly online and busy reading the posts. I would also like to thank the members for their professional comments and advice.
      As my first post in this forum I would like to ask the following queries:
      1-After running the analysis and design when I check the DESIGN DATA through Display >> Show Tables >> DESIGN DATA >> Concrete Frame Output, there is no specific message in Column Summary Data and Beam Summary Data, but in Joint summary data it is showing that “Joint B/C check not done”. Does anyone has any idea? I am sharing the ETABS model for your information and easy reference.
      ETABS MODEL.zip
      2- ETABS provides greater area of steel in the upper column than the column at BASE, perhaps due to higher moment. Could someone explain why this is so? In practice should we maintain maximum steel in both stories? Or we shall follow what the software suggests?
      3- Beside considering the minimum thickness required for deflection control of Beam as per Table 9.a Chapter 9 ACI-318 , using concrete crack behavior in ETABS and checking story drift, Do we have to check the deflection of beams for the serviceability propose elsewhere in ETBAS? If yes, Could anyone explain it?
      Regards, and look forward to any explanation
      • 13 replies
    • Posting this thread to break the ice. Modelling domes is very easy in Etabs/SAP. All you need to do is to draw the curvature of the dome in elevation by a series of straight lines, but draw only the one half. Then using the apex at centre point, radially extrude the line say 24 times at 15 degree intervals (or 48 times at 7.5 deg intervals. This feature is under Edit> Extrude Lines to areas. You can further use this geometry for Finite Element Analaysis.
      • 22 replies
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Jaher Wasim
      I am designing a 10 storied industrial building . Architect used a slanted wall in the front elevation of the building for aesthetic reason. But for structural framing I need to model this shear wall in ETABS. Is is possible in ETABS or I have to use any other software?
    • By Arash Pursadrullah
      Hi,
      I was wondering why in some cases when i want to check torsional irregularity in etabs and use Story Max/Avg Drift from Modal explorer,  the software shows both Y and X direction ratio for Earthquake in X direction Or vice versa. 
      as far as i know when checking for EX with plus and minus Eccentricities, it should only report ratios for X direction not Y! 
      i should mention that this happen only in few cases!! in most of the time software report only X direction ratio for EX!
      thanks in advance for your time.

    • By Aadelaadel Fd
      Dear all,
       
      please I need urgent help, I have etabs2015  model, it is highly required to be  opened using vesion 9.7.4
       
       
      moreover, in etabs  2015 how  to export mdp  file.
       
       
      best regards24414.2.EDB
    • By Rahulkld
      Is there any tutorials or references to design and analyse brick masonry in ETABS/SAP2000???
    • By SEs United
      dear all,
      i have some questions and i am hoping to find some answers from you kind people.
      1) when we use doubly reinforced beams how can be obtain economy be controlling ceiling height ?
      2) where do we use bar curtailment and bent up bars in beams because there are not ACI provisions related to bar curtailment (as far as i know)
      3)i have seen examples in books they calculate steel area for beams and they provide combination of different dia bars to satisfy that area why they do it because they can satisfy same area using same dia bars ?
      4)which design method Etabs uses. LRFD or ASD?
      5) how do we design the hanger bars. what is ACI provision for it?
      6)where do we use inclined stirrups in beams ?
      7) how the longitudinal reinforcing can be used as shear reinforcement ?
      Thank you all in advance. Looking forward to your responses.
    • By Waqas Haider
      Assalam o alaikum,
      Is there any suitable software available for concrete and steel quantities take of for all members like slab, column, beam, shear wall and foundation? especially which may work in conjunction with ETABS/SAP2000/SAFE. I found suggestions of some seniors to use SAFE for slab footing beam quantities but I want some specialized software where I can export my model of etabs or safe for quantity estimation? I just want to avoid time consumption for this purpose and speed up the process. Has any one listen about BLUEBEAM REVU software? I have heard about it but dont know in details.
    • By SEs United
      Hello dear Seniors,
      i am new to etabs i was designing a multistory plaza and when i ran the analysis following error occurred
      Warning: Area load transfer, Check StoryX, F659. Total loss = .......
      i have tried to re mesh my model using default meshing but it does not help can any one tell me whats wrong with my model.
      Please see the below picture for more info on the same issue
      Note: if i design the model while these error are present majority of my beams and columns fail, if i try to increase their sections to the max even then they dont satisfy......
       

    • By Waqas Haider
      Assalam o alaikum,
      I am having a building with a semi circle shape. None of the footing is either parallel to global X-axis nor to the global Y-axis. The plan of footings is attached. The problem I am facing is, ETABS reports joint reactions along global X-axis and global Y-axis instead of along the local axes of column. Since my columns are at a degree to global axis, the joint reactions also becomes at a degree from column and footing. Since to use simple combined stress formula of 
      stress = P/A + Mx*Y/Ix + My*X/Iy 
      I need forces along axis of footing. Or i will have to resolve either moment of inertia of footing along direction of forces or vice versa, which is quite tough and time taking. The other option I can go for is to design footing in SAFE. But again here, there i dont find any option to rotate footing at a certain degree to match orientation of columns. If i rotate local axis of footing, It only rotates its local axes and meshing but not the footing physically itself. The orientation of footing remains same. How can i solve this problem? Either having reactions in etabs along local axes of columns can solve my issue so that i can design it manually or rotating footing in safe to match local axes of columns can solve my issue. So can any one guide me how to do either option? Thanks.
    • By groszni awesome
      Assalamualaikum SE Pakistan, im about to design a retaining wall and would like to know is there any option/ is it possible to apply a triangular load on shells/paltes/membrane? or im just gonna model it as a 2D thing?
      regards
    • By Ussama Waseem
      Attached are two screenshots of the analysis of a continuous beam. One represents drop of loads from slabs with incorrect meshing(Auto meshing) and the other represents with correct meshing(manual meshing). Apparently, there is a big difference in the analysis results of the two mentioned by the circles. I posted it here to get further elaborations from the members to understand ETABS in a better way. Hope we can dig it more.


  • Recent Discussions

  • Latest Forum and Club Posts

    • Dear Shafqat, AA. Field work of a civil engineer generally consists of following activities: a. Surveying / levelling of the project area b. Supervision of construction work for buildings, roads, culverts, bridges etc., in accordance with detailed working drawings, applicable material specifications and quality standards. c. Preparation of material estimates, by calculating quantities of different items of work (e.g., excavation, concrete, brickwork, plaster, reinforcing steel etc-in case of buildings, and subbase, base, wearing course etc, in case of roadwork) included in working drawings of the project. 2. To perform all these tasks in better & efficient way, you will need to review your class notes & text books of relevant subjects (Surveying, Civil Engineering Practice, Estimating & Costing, Highways & Roads, Engineering Materials) taught during your civil engineering studies, in order to understand theoretical & practical aspects of these subjects. 3. As regards, which subject you should review first, would depend upon the work you are asked /assigned to do by your senior engineer. As a Trainee Engineer, you will certainly be attached with a senior engineer, who will assign you different engineering tasks & check your work. You may & must obtain his advice in all the work matters, where you are in doubt, or unclear about how to perform a given task. 4. In case you have futher querries, please do ask, by narrating your problem in detail. I will be happy to help you, as far as I can. By the way, what kind of civil works are carried out by your company mostly? Building work, roadwork or both? Regards.
    • Dear Shafqat Hussain Welcome to the forum. Check what you require at the job and discuss with your seniors, ask them for help if you do not understand something. At first job mostly you don not know exactly what to do but the main engineering profession skill is lifelong learning which comes forward and you learn new things. Contact some senior surveyor for the level and theodolite guidance.   Regards
    • , i just graduated as bachelor   in civil engineering i got the job in chinese company due to my chinese language skill but i don"t know knowledge about civil engineering so i need some information to continue this job because i can speak chinese and don't know about my major , my duty is as trainee engineer mean and i want  to get more  knowledge about level ,instrument measure  and theodolite    it will really great help that what kind of knowledge i should learn mean while  i will be waiting for reply 
    • Following are a few disadvantages of using higher strength rebars with a lower strength concrete: 1. Larger tension (as well as compression) development & lap-splice lengths will be required. 2. Overall load carrying capacity of a compression member will be lesser, compared with when higher strength concrete is used. 3. Maximum amount of steel reinforcement, that can be used in a flexural member, will also be lesser, thereby reducing its overall load carrying capacity. 4. Member size & self-weight will be somewhat larger, when steel yield strength is more than 60,000 psi. Regards.    
    • What kind of Problem may arise if High Strength Rebar is used with Low Strength Concrete. Say 3000 psi concrete with 72.5 grade rebar?
    • I agree with waqar. IMO, childern must be motivated towards & provided opportunities to play different health improving outdoor games (football, cricket, badminton, etc) , instead of watching TV or playing games on computer. My chidren are school going, and whenever they have done their homework, and it is pleasant outside (especially after Asr prayer), I send them out in a nearby park area. There they can play football or cricket, and can do exercise as well. On weekends, during vacations and on other days when they are unable to go outside, they generally watch tv for 1-2 hours.
    • Greetings All,   Technopole industries is a UAE based pole manufacturing factory which is currently in a requirement for a hard working, let me repeat that again an extremely hard working structural engineering to be part of our team. The Factory manufactures Steel poles & Mast more information can be found on Technopole Industries website. interested candidates can inbox me or drop their CV at fawad@technopoleindustries.com. Best Of Luck Guys
    • My kid is 2 nd 3 months old, we normally try to keep screen time as low as 1 hour/ 2 hour, when he watches cartoon or use mobile for game more than 2 hours, he becomes too difficult to handle. So we bought books that we read with him like picture stories and take him outside where he can play, run and climb monkey bar etc, after playing  he becomes satisfied and easy to handle. that's my personal experience :-). Regards
    • hi umar, thanks a lot for your valuable links. Best Regards   
    • Wsalaam... That is the general principle, however I was wondering if people could share their personal experiences.  Here is an article about it as well: http://www.cbc.ca/news/health/screen-time-preschool-1.4140491 Thanks.
×

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Guidelines.