Rana

Etabs Load Combinations

14 posts in this topic

ETABS Load Combo Creation


Have a look at it...may be u find it useful...its for manually creating combos in excel and then importing back to etabs..as it allows the flexibility to create combinations in table format and less chances for errors as compared with that of ETABS unfriendly load combo interface...Report back any bugs or suggestions...thanks

To download click on the link above with blue color
or
www.4shared.com/file/THoXlkzv/ETABS_Load_Combo.html

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

one can use default combo

Default have a lot of issues unless you know what you are doing. Make sure you configure them properly with dead load multipliers for seismic. How many load cased do you define for your seismic case?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i have experience in making load combinations in etabs at quite complex level...believe it or not for some buildings i have made 200 ultimate and 200 service combinations...i really hate the etabs combination dialogue box which cannot be resized...unlike SAFE! where you can export it into excel! anyway this sheets i just designed for my own custom application...thought to share with you guyz if you find it helping..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

look! first you need to study code for proper load combinations. This is very very critical. All the design results and serviceability criteria is based on it.

You need to understand which load combination to use and when to use.

Read chapter 9 of ACI and PCA Notes..Read its commentary..Read UBC...Try to know what is the difference between 1.3W of UBC and 1.6W of ACI.
Get to know why the factor in E is 1.0 in strength load combinations. Know why omega factor is used.

2nd...Research what are the options in softwares which affect automatic load combination creation. For example in ETABS what is the impact of code you select for concrete or steel design and the seismic design category? Why there is SPECIAL SEISMIC LOADS option in ETABS under define menu?

I would recommend you to print the page of ACI where load combinations are defined and also for UBC and keep it in front of you!..Take a paper and write all the appplicable load combinations based on your load cases. Then compare ACI vs UBC

I would say you dont use automatic load combinations rather make your own combinations.

Once you are done and confident about your understanding of load combinations then use the AUTOMATIC load combinations.

You should know which combination is appropriate for Seismic drift limit or wind drift limit. What is the meaning of probability or exceedence of seismic or wind forces?

If still this all stuff seem boring to you! do this

Goto options in ETABS> define design code to be ACI 2008..Select appropriate seismic design category. If you are not familiar with SDC open chapter 1 of ACI and see what is the equivalent SDC of UBC in Table 1.1 of ACI

Then goto define menu>Special seismic forces.

If your SDC is C or less it will not have an impact. So you select it or not...doesnt matter

then create automatic load combinations and verify them one by one..Do this atleast in your first few models.

There is a trick to make service load combinations automatic too...if you are interested i will tell you later! :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

thanks alot for your response.........let me study it first

its good that you said that you want to study it first, rather following it blindly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Rana bhai where is the trick??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Rana sir the load combination creation file is missing ..... kindly upload it again, i need it......

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dear friends

what are the most critical load combinations(service and strength) for zone 2B please.

Regards

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

2 hours ago, waqar saleem said:

what are the most critical load combinations(service and strength) for zone 2B please.

it would depend upon the material of construction being used. In general, load combinations involving seismic (earthquake) effects will be critical for RC structures. Whereas, for steel structures, those involving wind effects will be more critical.

In practice however we check the structures for structural safety against the load combinations (specified by applicable material design / loading codes) involving all type of loads that are expected to be resisted by the structure during its entire design life. 

Regards.

Edited by EngrUzair

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By waqar saleem
      Dear fellows!
      I have observed that some senior engineers have not been using stiffness modifiers in their designs. What is the concept behind  i am not clear . As we design RC for strength, section is cracked and to cater for this cracked section, property modifiers are used as per
       ACI 318-11  10.10.4 (stiffness requirement)

       ACI 318-11  8.7 (stiffness requirement)


      UBC97 1630.1.2 (modelling requirement)
       so why whole section is considered in design. is there any other logic which i couldn't understand.
       
      Regards
    • By Mehdi_
      As you know, we are forced to convert the ETABS results to executive drawings. This is a time consuming job. Is there any software that accept ETABS outputs and generate drawings? Specially for a reinforced concrete structure.
       
    • By Engr Waqas
      Assalam o alaikum,
      I was reading ETABS concrete frame design manual ACI 318-08. In beam design section, it gives two formulae which I am unable to find in books. One formula for stress block depth and one formula for negative steel calculation. I have highlighted the formulae in below images. The manual design using these formulae and conventional formulae gives the same result. But kindly guide me from where I can get derivation of these formulae or theory behind this.